Ah, The Benefits of Central Planning

This article in the LA Times points out some of the cultural differences between American and Chinese societies, as well as some of the related political differences. Interesting observations.

It sounds good to me to not have to deal with hearings, environmental impact reports, high-priced labor, etc. Maybe LA would have a modern airport if we lived in that kind of environment! BUT, Americans would not give up their right to "participation," even with the accompanying lack of progress.

Primary factors I see in the Chinese ability to make fast and huge changes are:
1. The people's acquiescence to government action because of their belief that the relative good for society outweighs the personal cost they have to bear for progress. A supporting factor for this, but not the dominant factor that Americans would like to think it is, is their lack of recourse. Americans do not understand this profound difference in worldview and values.
2. The minimal cost of labor, which I would guess is roughly $5/day compared to probably $100/day in the US.
3. The lack of checks and balances in their top-down system, which ensures expedient action for decisions made by the leaders.

China seems little hindered by the pressures that plague transit projects in the West.

Financial woes sandbagged New York's Second Avenue subway for about 80 years until ground was broken this spring. L.A.'s subway system, whose westward march was halted at Western Avenue in 1996, has been constricted by environmental, political and financial pressures.

In China, labor is cheap, the land belongs to the government, air pollution is the primary environmental concern, and political pressure moves largely in one direction -- from the Communist Party leadership on down.

"If the government wants to do something, even if the conditions are not ready for it, it will be done," said Zheng Shiling, an influential Chinese architect who teaches at Tongji University in Shanghai.